philip larkin's famous poem haunts me:
this be the verse
they fuck you up, your mum and dad
they may not mean to, but they do.
they fill you with the faults they had
and add some extra, just for you.
but they were fucked up in their turn
by fools in old-style hats and coats,
who half the time were soppy-stern
and half at one another's throats.
man hands on misery to man.
it deepens like a coastal shelf.
get out as early as you can,
and don't have any kids yourself.
but larkin's advice comes too late for me (miraculously, wondrously too late!) and now i'm left wondering how exactly i'm going to mess molly's little life and if i've even done some damage already. i know, i know - all i can do is my best and there's no point in getting into paralysing navel-gazing, but there's also something healthy in my paranoia. in being aware of the potential for harm my hope is that i can mitigate against at least some of it.
alli and i have spent an inordinate amount of time thinking about how we will teach molly about the issues surrounding sex and sexuality. from mtv, to billboard advertising, to disney, molly is growing up in a culture that is obsessed with sex and ambivalent about sexuality.
molly is also blessed/cursed with a dad who (over)thinks pretty much everything, pretty much all the time. i love her so much and am determined to do everything within my power to help her actualise her full potential. yet, at the same time, i recognise that there are principalities and powers that are, even right now, waging war against her. molly has not arrived in a world which celebrates equality and justice for all. there is a perfidious patriarchy, a heterosexual hegemony at work in our culture against which, and within which, alli and i are determined to help her fight.
one's sex is biologically determined - we are born male, female or intersex; our gender, however, is a different matter. while some argue that masculine and feminine characteristics are innate, most people accept that culture plays a significant role in their construction. radical feminists believe masculine and feminine are entirely societal constructs and this belief has led to the decision of a swedish couple not to divulge the sex of their child to anyone outside of the small group involved in changing the child's diapers/nappies. they do not use pronouns when referring to the child, known only as "pop", and, while not making any attempt to hide pop's sex from popself, they want to do all they can to ensure their child is seen as a person first and is not limited by cultural expectations as to what is, or is not, appropriate for a particular gender.
many people have been horrified by this decision; some have even said it is abusive, which is ridiculous. i think the parents are courageous. some object to parents pushing their ideological beliefs on their child before that child is able to give informed consent, but doesn't every parent do this anyway? we impose our standards of right and wrong and often our religious sensibilities without pausing to consider whether the child should have the right to opt out of this indoctrination. in this regard, these parents are no different.

even language is against molly. it makes me mad to think that some may hold molly's sex against her. if molly shows a proclivity for acting, some will call her an "actress" - in the 21st century! why would her gender be a factor in her occupation? will she be an engineeress, a teacheress, a directoress, or a politicianess? it's patronising and ridiculous. it's also infuriating that the pay gap between men and women is actually widening in canada, the us and the uk - what's that all about? molly has a struggle ahead of her.
so, how are we to help equip her for the struggle? it can't simply be a matter of one talk when she's older - culture is what we swim in. all the time. we want to give molly some tools and questions and stories she can draw on when she finds herself conflicted in this crazy mixed-up world.
at the moment, our big concern is the stories we tell molly. fairy tales are (as chesterton put it) "the wisest things in the world, at any rate the wisest things of worldly origin." the stories we tell one another are the distilled essence of everything we truly, in our very heart-of-hearts, believe. so, when we actually analyse these tales for their wisdom, what do we learn:
- being rich equals being happy
- girls need to find a man to be complete
- hetrosexual love is the only game in town
- girls are damsels in distress, needing to be rescued (by a guy, of course)
- single women are evil witches
- step-mothers should be feared
much has been written of the gender inequality in disney and pixar. have you ever looked closely at how women are portrayed in these movies? it is shameful! there are some exceptions to the rule: fiona is a pretty strong character in shrek; mulan, pocahontas. however, try finding any accompanying merchandise for these characters and you will, almost certainly, be out of luck. shrek and donkey are two-a-penny; fiona and mulan - rare collectors' pieces. are these the stories which will shape molly?
what about the stories that will come to molly from the church? to be honest, i don't think it is any different from the message she would get from the secular world around her: stories told by men, about men, for men. i've written much about this before, so i will refrain from commenting, other than to say how encouraged i was to read about jimmy carter's recent decision to sever all formal ties with the southern baptist church over its doctrinal stance on the inequality of women. perhaps the story is changing?
there has to be a different way. would it surprise you to hear that in many eastern and third world traditions the stories centre around people who actually give up their wealth in order to achieve wisdom (including, of course, the life story of siddhārtha gautama, the buddha himself)? they recognise at least one central truth: that being wise is more important than being rich. in japanese anime females are often the lead character. in fact, this is so much the case that it is rarely noted by japanese kids when they are watching - it's not a girl, it's a person - a hero! in the west male is always the generic gender; female is always particular.
all these things have led us to examine the stories we are already reading to molly and to think very carefully about which stories which will be the soundtrack to her growing up and how we can tell them to her.
so what do you think? how do you cope living with such inequality, whether expressed and implicit? how do you encourage the next generation to overcome it?
teach, o wise ones, teach!
Recent Comments